Get Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization PDF

By R Brock, S Hodkinson

ISBN-10: 0198152205

ISBN-13: 9780198152200

ISBN-10: 0199258104

ISBN-13: 9780199258109

ISBN-10: 0585486069

ISBN-13: 9780585486062

ISBN-10: 1423767675

ISBN-13: 9781423767671

This quantity comprises eighteen essays by way of demonstrated and more youthful historians that study non-democratic replacement political platforms and ideologies--oligarchies, monarchies, combined constitutions--along with assorted sorts of communal and nearby institutions comparable to ethnoi, amphiktyonies, and confederacies. The papers, which span the size and breadth of the Hellenic international spotlight the large political flexibility and variety of old Greek civilization.

Show description

Read Online or Download Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece PDF

Similar history_1 books

Read e-book online A Concise Historical Grammar of the Albanian Language: PDF

This paintings addresses the old improvement of the Albanian language from prehistoric occasions to the twenty first century. the focus of the e-book is the reconstruction of Proto-Albanian, the research of its relatives to its ancestor, Indo-European, and its extra switch resulting in Albanian in its current shape.

Download e-book for kindle: Thomas Harriot’s Artis Analyticae Praxis: An English by Muriel Seltman, Robert Goulding

Thomas Harriot's "Artis analyticae praxis" is a necessary paintings within the heritage of algebra. to some degree it's a improvement paintings of Viete, who used to be one of the first to exploit literal symbols to face for identified and unknown amounts. however it used to be Harriot who took the the most important step of making a wholly symbolic algebra, in order that reasoning will be decreased to a quasi-mechanical manipulation of symbols.

Daily Life of the Aztecs, 2nd Edition (The Greenwood Press by Davíd Carrasco, Scott Sessions PDF

Everyday life of the Aztecs дает описания жизни ацтеков от низов до верхних этажей их социальной пирамиды. В книге рассказывается о взаимодействии между материальным и творческий миром ацтеков через отношения внутри общины, игры, образование и искусство, а также жертвенные ритуалы. Авторы также подробно изображают эволюцию ацтекского государства и исследуют ацтекские символы, мифы и ритуалы от древности до настоящего времени.

Additional resources for Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece

Example text

Robinson (1997). For the impact of Aristotle’s outlook on his account of Sparta see Schutrumpf (1994). • See Gauthier (1993), esp. 217–25, and Gruen (1993); this is also the underlying theme of Rhodes with Lewis (1997), esp. 531–6. 14 Roger Brock and Stephen Hodkinson Constitutional diversity We need to bear in mind both the di¶culty of reliable definition and the impact of the Athenian outlook and agenda when we examine the range of constitutions found in classical Greece. In the case of democracy, the Athenian model can be particularly unhelpful, and we should be wary of assuming that it is to be inferred wherever we hear of a democracy.

On all the varieties of oligarchy see Whibley (1896) ch. 4, still the standard text after a century. On fixed number at Athens see Brock (1989). Aristotle seems to concede up to a point the claims of Sparta and Carthage that their use of election for o¶ce reflects a concern to select the best men (1293B7–18)—though he is famously scathing about the Spartan mechanism of election—while remaining clear that they are oligarchic in operation (and Sparta formally a mixed constitution: 1294B18–34). Matters are further complicated by the proximity of aristocracy to ‘polity’ in his constitutional schema (on which see Andrew Lintott’s contribution) and by an ambiguous definition which also embraces constitutions directed towards what is best for the state and its members (1279A35–7).

As his analysis indicates, there was throughout Greek history a fluctuating balance between ideological consciousness and pragmatism, and between structural and contingent factors, in the choices and alterations which Greek communities made regarding their political systems. Radical change at the state level could be precipitated not only by ideological concerns but also by personal ones, often financial, familial, or sexual: the fifth book of the Politics contains a rich selection of examples. The implication for modern views of the Greek polis is that we should abandon the angle of vision in which classical Athenian d»emokratia appears as the central point of Greek political experience for a perspective which sees it within a much broader context—a context very unlike the presentday ideological dominance of liberal democracy in which a range of political regimes could lay claim to legitimacy both as viable systems in their own right and as potential models for imitation by their neighbours.

Download PDF sample

Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece by R Brock, S Hodkinson


by Jeff
4.4

Rated 4.90 of 5 – based on 32 votes